746344

Difputatio X l X. SeéHo

'tp14fl p11n1m hominem c..l11mi1A1i

h11m11n~

fhbie–

llHm,

(

'JHOd pudtt dicere)flr1111m thm irnp'J

ingrttti t11111i1

beneficii~liber11torun

noflr11m no11prr-

1imrfci1i1 fJtnon•f" f11uce fii{MTflrt,

non fJtrt–

mini 'jHert1fi obtrcél111ore1 Deo

odibi/~J

iOi.mfmmm

n11mc11p11rt,q•I( vo1 de fcrui1111< Di11boli libm111i1

vbi abfólute damnar dicentes Chníl:um cíl'e

feruum. t r q111dcm vcherr.entcr inuehitur

Elipanduln , ciufquc foq,uaccs <¡uod dixcrinr,

Chrillum

fcruum

quam quod

~1xerint

fü1um adoptiuum; id enim cxprcffir il lis ver–

Lis (

& q11od pudtt

dicere)eofque ceníct impios

ingraros, Dao odibilcs, qocrulos obtrelb–

rores;

vcti~n'ofo

fauce fufurramcs. Audiamr

Conciliunt

Pr~ncofordienfe

ép.

ad Epifco–

pos H1fpa'ifüc, vbi poíl:quam ílarnit Chriíl:om

non dft ·dicehd

um fernu

m, neqne adopciuum,

fic

concludíc :

lmellft.ir

¡,,,,

ptofrffio11e fJej/ra

duplim Dl4io/i,4fr4:idiJ /.,111iJ[edolo1,hoc rfl i.t

VDJ

qui gr41/a biptifmi redm1 ti eflü, ab vniia–

te C4rh1lic• diflnn.gtrtr eccl1fi.e,rJ¡j:hifmarici rrro–

riJ laqueo

via'fdlmiJ 1.1er1t'rttr.1heru,&gtnri–

hHJ

inttr qrlM h.1bitarl1

( nlmitum

~hhCJmc

tanos)

Chrij/i1111•ftdri

;,,,,;.,.

i111rrdHdtrtt,d11m

Dominr1r11 >10/lrld'n le/ur11 Cbri/111111,q11em Deum

colim111

aáornm111,fm1~111 prldi~a1i1, ~

adop–

ti11Nm;

vbi in vtcoquc :u11c1tlo de

ru1tutc,&

adoption~ait

cos fch1smarico crrorc

~Diabolo

fuiffe dclufos:fcd arnculus de adoptione tíl:

damnacus, ncc porcíl: d, fcnd1:crgo ctiam a1ti–

culus de fcruirute. Mult:r 111dem folutioncs

adhibcri folcnr h1s auétonuubus,quas optj–

me!fnpugnam P.Vazq.& Lugo omnino con·

fulend1.Sed omnes fcrc folutio11cs pra:occupá–

tar,(i aduerratur quod Pontifcx,& Concil1um

non cxcludunr vnam,v

2lccram fcru1ru1em ,

fed omncm,qnia l'on11fcx & Concili<lm ncgéc

feru1tutem Chníl:o Domino, id prob>iit,qu1a

numquam in nouo te!larr.ento Chriíl:us voca–

tus c!l feruus,in vercn amcm tcíl:amcnto folú

trop1ce did fcruum ccnfcnr:ícd

aliquod ve·

rum

genus fcruitncis

cí!Ct

in Chníl:o , de illa

dcbcrct Pomifcx inrelligcrc loca vctcris tc!la–

mcnti,& 11011 dcbcrct aJdcrc q11od ibi tropi–

ce loqua1ur,qui2 quotics Scnptura dmina'in

vero ícnfu intclligi poteíl:, ira dtbet intdligi,

non in lcufu mccaphorico: trgo

in Chri–

!lo dfe1 aliqna vera feruitus,dc

poífent in–

tcllig1 pra:d1lb loca Scriprnr:r, vr inccll1gunr

Doétorco prima: fcntcndx : ergo cum Ponti–

fex

ccnfeat quod loca vctcris teíl:amenti qua:

Chri!lo 1ribuunr fcruirncem,non Íu111 imelli–

genda proprie , lignum dl quod nullam in

Chriílo \'Cram foruitucem agnofcac.Quod

có–

firm~t

Ponufex ex eo quod in nouo 1ell•méto

numquam

hri!lus dicarnr fcruus,

indc 1n–

ferr quod nulla in co !ic feruirns,quod auccm

Ponrifcx ira íenriac,cóílorcx il lius verbis, rocis

enim ingcni¡ viribus contcndi1

explicarcomn~

loca vcteris tc!lamfo,qmbus vidctur Chriílus

feruusappell.n, Reípondetc¡uc hoc modo:Na

<!J

in vmbrti prtpheri4 di[l..,

t{I

{mlHJ

propter

fa,.;¡;,

J•rm• condi1io11tm,q11odfu:npfit ex flirgine,

jic111f<rip111111 ej/;ron(iderafli fmwm me11m Job,&

hoc no1 vn11 c11111

Gregorio ime//1gimm,&ftcirn–

d11m hij/oridm de SanElo lob

allegorice de

Chri'j/o diElitm:nmnquid ferni ti >1omtn impontre

debemu1

c¡aiafub ptr{ona lob Scrip111rn mm

IJ·

pice dcfig11111,dei11deillud Pf.11

.Egofer111u tm11,

fili111

1111ci//~

11<4,& Pf8

.f11lm1m fac jirium nn-

ti/11111,.,&

lfRi.44 noli 1lmere fer11u1 mt1l1 ftteob,

ua: cdlimoma eodtm modo , ncmpe rro–

prco:~

J1iego11co fenfu in rdhgir Pon11fex,&:

fubd1c 1nfrn,quod in nouo rdlamcmo,vbi crf–

fouic vmbra

allegoria, numquam Ch11fius

diétus lir fcruus:do vecba Pout1fic1s.Po.fl1•Rnl

1111ttm ceffe11i1fJmbra vm'wu,tf;r ipf

a inpromp1

,¡

ma11ifall111~

efl vtrira1,

q••fi.b

41/

egoricn.fy/11.c

lttttb4t,

n11mq11am e11m

Parre

flrnurn

VQCat11rn

imeOigim111 ,fld

ftiikm,&

J,/eélum f•um.

Emm–

vero in ipfqttiam

m1iculo

paffioni1,111 '}Hofaruilis

forma pari

f'"""'

erar ,fJb1 omni1 h11mnn.t condi–

tiOrltÍ mfirmitlll

monjlrabtttur,non

ettm

Domirmrn

1<ppe/11111it ,fed Patr<m,Parer lnq11i1 ,fi fteri

po–

tefl,mmftttt

cnli.\'

ij!t,

quoniam

rnagn1trn

pir111ri1{acr11mentHm

q•oá 11pp11r.,ir in 11111ndo,

foxtt< Panli voctm, adfi1mp1um

tfl

ingtori"

NHI–

¡.,

vnq11am Enangelij/arnm, nemo Apoflolor11m,

ftr1111m tHmcommemarat,ftá

Dommttm,

S11/~

111ttorem.

Ergo

in Chnílo Oonllrío

clfor

ali–

qua vera foruicus

, cam nobis dedara!fcc

nonum tlílamtn1om,quod ciare nobis •rc1it

nanrram ,

propricrarcs

h11f11 Oomrni.

Confirmacur,omnis íeru11us,

vcl

feruirus

peccaco, ,,.,

Í•ruÍtus 'qua vous homo

fcruus alcerius, vel Angeli,vel Dei:

Íi

dom–

ncm hanc fcrniunem cxcludic Concilium

Francofordmife

hriíl:o Domino : ergo

nullo modo Chrifrus efl

fcruus. Prob•cur

maior ex verb1s Concih¡.

Hoc volmma

"lJob11

nudire,an Adam primiu hu111ani generÍ4 Pattr,

'l";

de rerra vir¡,ine eo11di1m efl ,/.her fi1eri1 <0n–

di11u,anferHm

librr:9H111e

Chrif/¡u

1fOtl

intt•

ni1111

virgine,&e. fJnde

.Ad11111 íer11u1 J.1El1u

cjlnijiex peceA1',Chriflu1 11111em 11onfuit pee·

c«111111,ideoítr11111 non

•JI

pewui.ftd magü libera-

~:~~c~~~;~r:;; :·;;~<lf;

~(~~;,¡u~;n~:::;:~

orram ex pcccaro : ergo li aliis vcrbis fubíc–

qucncibus cxclud1t alias feruitures , non

lo–

quicur de feruicute peccati : fed Concilium

eas cmnes excludic : ergo nullam conccdic

Chn!lo. Probarur minoc ex

bis eiufdcm

Concilij.Sedfortt[<runm hominu eumfi1iffe di–

citti, 'l"itl ef1 t¡Hod dicit Propheta, DrU6 i11dici11111

tttmn Regida,& iH/lirinm tttalfl filio Rtgi•,&c.&

hocfapius reperitllr

q1111m txemplsi indigea1 tlo–

cert

'1"º" Jit

DommuJ cmnium

non

11lici1i111

ftru111,anne

.Angrlon~rn

ftrtmm

t11m

t;t1l1is

diccrt

qtti11 diE/11mej/;mim1ifti mm paHlo mimu

.An–

gelu? 'tltiq11e 111i11.ratH1 tj/ propttr mor1ali1atem

C1trnU.nonpropttr conJitioniJ ftr1Ji1J

km,

Dcniquct

probar nec Pnrris,fcilicct Dei

ruum appel–

landum his verbis,

Quid diciri1 de Deo Paire,

'l"j

eum in hapti{m1,

tli11m

tramfig11rationr,

qu.t.faE/a rfl in mo11tt,

fitittm nomin111,it

non

feri.t1m,hi' en

pu,,,

TntllJ diltEJm,in

'1''º

tnihi btnt

complarni.

oncílium a\ltcm non ignorauic

Chrifrum íecundum n•1Uram humanam , eífe

creacui.n

Deo,& ab eo drpcndenrcm,iJ1 quo

Doétorcs primx fcntcntia! confrirnunc

{ir–

uitucem na1uralcm ;

nihilominus dixic

hnílnm non clfc feruum Dei Patris:ergo Íe-

cundum Concilij mcntcm omnis

Íi

ruitus ne-

ganda ell Chriílo.

Quid

dim

Secundo probJrur rat1one, quoncs 111

ali-

fcruicu< cilé–

quo non

ctl

d,quod

clfential11ec óidc ratio cialitcr

fr111ituris,non

poi.fl

in eo cífe frruitus:fcd in

Chriilo non eíl: id,quod dfrntialmc dirit ra-

tio feruicuiis:ergo in Chriílo non cíl fcruims.

Proba